Saturday, January 10, 2015

The Recall



I need to break the fourth wall and interrupt my own stream of consciousness dialogue to discuss a couple things outside of my standard narrative voice. Looking back at the last several of my posts, it’s easy to sense my frustration with a lot of things around me in India, which normally isn’t the case when I travel, even in the developing world. It’s true that India has been the biggest leap in terms of culture that I’ve made thus far in my life, but it hasn’t been an issue for me ever before. Even though I don’t think a travelogue needs to always have a positive narrative (Bill Bryson is one of my literary heroes and that dude could bitch like a champ), it still didn’t seem to really have the voice that I wanted to share about India.

 The truth is that I’m not terribly pleased with the course I am taking here, for reasons that I won’t get into here, but overall there have been several points of frustration for not only me but my fellow classmates as well. I realize now how much that has affected my mode, and therefore my perceptions of India overall. I know now that I cannot be an impartial jury while here, and so I’m issuing a recall of my previous posts. Not the factual parts, for what I have said about India remains true, but in how it has struck me and how I feel about the land and the people. As I said in my previous post, I will need to return to India on my own terms, and hopefully that day will come sooner rather than later.

The blog will continue, though the narrative, scope and subject matter will probably change a bit as I complete posts for the course. I can assure you however, that India remains as wild and crazy as you could ever imagine.

Friday, January 9, 2015

The Quest



You never forget your time exchanging pleasantries with a fully clothed man while sitting butt naked on a stool on a warm Kerala afternoon. 

This is spiritual India, the one that has attracted scores of westerners over the past decades including the Beatles and Steve Jobs. Whether it’s the gurus, the yoga, the aryuvedic medicine, there’s something here tied deeply to the people, their religious beliefs and cultures, that is magnetic for people from all over the world. 

Almost two weeks into our trip I’m coming to understand that this is the part that draws people to India, and what gives it such a mythical status in the realm of spiritual quest seekers. They don’t come for the party culture, or the cities or the scenic beaches, which was something I had been struggling with for the past few days. What exactly is the draw of India?

So many of the people I know who have been to India exhibited such a strong affection of their time here, but two weeks into the trip and struggling to understand why I don’t feel like I’m making the same connection. Without doubt I am glad that I am here, and find India fascinating in every way, like most of those who have come before me. But I also feel that India has yet to truly pull me in, to make me yearn to return only weeks after I’ve departed. Rightly or wrongly, I had somewhat assumed that it would just happen here.

I think part of it is the cities. I love cities, they’re my favorite part of travel, and we’ve spent so much time in the Kerala cities of Kochi and Trivandrum over the past two weeks. But people do not visit India for the cities. They are congested and dirty, and unfortunately by dirty I mean the dirtiest I have seen. I know this doesn’t represent the whole of India, but it represents the part of which I’ve been the most exposed, and it’s been challenging to witness how cities are put together here and the lifestyle they encompass. 

I know there’s more out there, and this represents the problem of only having 3 weeks, and a restricted 3 weeks at that due to class requirements, to really experience a country. 

And with that I found myself sitting down on a stool for my aryuvedic massage, understanding that it would be a chance to experience a slice of the alternative medicine tradition here that is so popular, and maybe connect a little more with the spiritual side of India. 

I’m not a spiritual person, so perhaps it’s not a surprise that I failed to find the connection here once again. It was a new experience to be sure, and again something I’m glad I had the chance to do, but mostly it left me feeling oily and confused, and I walked out thinking about how according to the dudes in robes who used to instruct me on right versus wrong, I was now supposed to go into a little closet and confess what just happened to me. 

What I look for instead of spirituality in traveling is humanity, and a connection to the people and places I am visiting through local interactions and adventures. And this I think is the other missing piece of the puzzle. Being in a program here, almost everything, save for a few hours for dinner each night, is planned out for us. The challenges of arranging travel, securing lodging, and navigating the people and cultures, are all taken care of for us. With my hands washed of all of this, I simply find myself writing about not being able to connect with a place from the lobby of my luxury hotel, and staring out of the window of our pre-arranged bus as it ferries us from one place to the next. 

I think if anything I will owe India another visit, a chance to truly experience it the way I would choose, and to see how it would feel when viewed through my own lens. It won’t be through a spiritual lens, as so many from the west choose to do, but I do think there’s an India out there for me.

Tuesday, January 6, 2015

What it is to burn



If you’re a listener of the Freakonomics podcast, it’s likely you’ve listened to this episode in which they explore selective outrage, and the types of things we decide to become angered and active about, and those which we do not. One of the central ideas explored in the episode is the idea of anger against animal cruelty and how something that has traditionally occupied such a relatively unimportant position in society can rise to prominence as an issue, even above things such as warfare and violence that we usually consider much worse.

The reason, as posited in the episode, is that we care because we can. By living in an industrialized first world country, many of the concerns and issues that have traditionally affected society have been eradicated or minimalized to the extent that they no longer seem to be such an endemic. Food is plentiful, medicine effective and available, freedom of choice often in existence, and by and large for the most of us peace reigns in our lands. Beyond our borders many of the troubles that have plagued mankind still ravage distant populations, but because of the distance, both spatial and cultural, they do not command the same urgency amongst us as before. Instead we are left to focus on issues such as organic dog food, hybrid vehicles, and whether or not it’s justifiable to kill a single giraffe in the name of empathy.

I came to India enrolled in a winter session class titled “Ecotourism and Sustainable Development in India” to explore this idea of how these ideas which are considered luxuries of the industrialized world could be pursued and implemented in a developing nation with much more traditional and tangible problems. The task is not an easy one, and especially compared to the Western world, which took generations to move from industrialization to a society in which environmental considerations are at least on the table. With their own “civil wars” still raging at home, is it possible to get the people of India to even care about Marius the giraffe, to borrow from the Freakonomics metaphor?

Thus far the exploration to the topic has been interesting, but at the same time has left me inconclusive about these issues as they relate to India. We’ve spent the first week in lectures and site visits with individuals from some really amazing groups here in India who not only are pushing sustainability, and eco-friendly development and construction principles, but social welfare improvements through low income housing, clean water initiatives and waste management efforts. The power of the work they do is truly inspiring, especially when viewed through the lens of the beautiful buildings and developments they create, ones that manage to incorporate all of the above principles along with impressive aesthetics. 

But as positive and impactful as their work truly is, it can be hard to ignore the miles and miles of developments along the road we drive each day that represent the complete opposite of everything they are working to achieve at Inspiration and Costford. Here the streets are lined with hastily constructed concrete structures, the grounds are littered with either discarded trash or burning trash piles, and the open sewers run with untreated sewage. Looking out through the calmness of the bus window, it’s hard not to think of these two types of developments here in India, and then think of the relative scale to which one persists over the other. 

Kerala prides itself on having achieved such a high level of development relative to the rest of India over the past several decades with respect to education, health, women’s rights, literacy and many other issues. Through various initiatives it has managed to achieve a relatively high human development index despite a lack of heavy industrial development, and often boasts that today it is able to meet many of the basic needs of its citizens that are not often met in other developing states and countries.

So if the basic needs are met and the people of Kerala are free to live safe and happy lives, does that make it easier to push luxury issues such as sustainability and environmentally friendly development? Despite the efforts of those around us in this program, it still seems like a difficult sell here in one of India’s most densely populated states. It’s hard to imagine advanced environmental initiatives such as biogas generation and recycling programs gaining much traction here when trash, litter, soot and sewage make up such a prominent part of the urban landscape. And it leaves me wondering, are we fooling ourselves exploring the ideas of sustainability here when many of these basic needs are not being met, despite what might be said otherwise? Or is it simply a cultural matter, as has been suggested: that the differences in cleanliness here are not viewed as an issue, and the trash in the street and the sewage in the gutter simply just a part of life in Kerala and nothing more.

To me the former makes more sense, but the implications likely represent the sad reality, that the ideas of sustainability and environmentally friendly will remain for the most part a luxury good. From this it’s difficult to envision a way in which the developing world does not follow the same path as the developed, with an extended period of growth at the expense of their environment, which will in time allow it to achieve the levels of prosperity required to become passionate towards undoing the damage caused by said growth. But the major difference is that in India, a country of 1.2 billion people, the stakes are that much higher.